THE FULL RECORD
Experiment Log
Every combination we've tried, in the order we tried it — the wins, the misses, and everything in between. Ratings are out of five and reflect our honest take, not a sales pitch.
★★★★★
Rye Whiskey
Cynar
Apricot Liqueur
Lemon Juice
A drier, more angular riff on the Paper Plane. Cynar's vegetal bitterness plays beautifully against the apricot liqueur's stone fruit sweetness. The exact apricot liqueur wasn't specified on the menu — we're treating it as a placeholder until we can confirm or pick our favorite.
★★★★★
Tequila Reposado
Aperol
St. Germain
Lemon Juice
A tequila-forward riff on the Paper Plane discovered on the menu at Ocean Prime. The reposado's oak and St. Germain's elderflower play beautifully against Aperol's bitterness.
★★★★★
Gin
St. Germain
Amaro Nonino
Lemon Juice
Prosecco Float
Equal parts gin, St. Germain, Amaro Nonino, and lemon — topped with a prosecco float. Floral and effervescent, this one drinks like a celebration. A favorite for warm-weather gatherings.
★★★★★
Bourbon
Aperol
Amaro Nonino
Lemon Juice
Where it all started. Named after the M.I.A. song and created at one of Chicago's spiritual siblings — Milk & Honey in New York. The benchmark against which every riff is measured. If you haven't tried the original, start here.
More experiments coming soon — including some notable failures worth documenting.